Progress: 1 down, 19 to go
Which: Water for Elephants, Sara Gruen
I love Carnivàle and unfortunately that’s what I hoped for when I cracked open Water for Elephants. It’s not bad, really, but…in the world of the Dust Bowl circus: Knauf’s writing, Brother Justin, and that title sequence! are a damn hard act to follow.
The story trundles along at a good clip, to Gruen’s credit; there’s not much time to grow too impatient with anyone¹. I’ll be it translates pretty well to film. Plus, Christoph Waltz as the schizophrenic animal trainer? I am in.
¹ Except maybe with Gruen? Jacob isn’t unsympathetic and, as the wife of an unhinged and abusive husband, neither really is Marlena, but they’re not actively sympathetic either. That was frustrating. 

Progress: 1 down, 19 to go

Which: Water for Elephants, Sara Gruen

I love Carnivàle and unfortunately that’s what I hoped for when I cracked open Water for Elephants. It’s not bad, really, but…in the world of the Dust Bowl circus: Knauf’s writing, Brother Justin, and that title sequence! are a damn hard act to follow.

The story trundles along at a good clip, to Gruen’s credit; there’s not much time to grow too impatient with anyone¹. I’ll be it translates pretty well to film. Plus, Christoph Waltz as the schizophrenic animal trainer? I am in.

¹ Except maybe with Gruen? Jacob isn’t unsympathetic and, as the wife of an unhinged and abusive husband, neither really is Marlena, but they’re not actively sympathetic either. That was frustrating. 

3 Jul 2010   [ books reading 20 by NYE ]

← Up nextPreviously →